The evidence
Which sales psychology studies actually replicated
Every study cited in The Fourth Bottle, with its headline figure and what happened when other researchers tried to reproduce it. Published here in full rather than buried in an appendix.
8
hold up as usually reported
12
real but conditional, or single-study
3
contested, failed, or smaller than reported
3
not experiments at all
4
meta-analyses and syntheses that judge the rest
Why this page exists
Open any book about selling and you will meet the same dozen studies. They appear so often, and so confidently, that it is reasonable to assume somebody checked them. Mostly nobody has. Four or five retellings back there is a real paper, and it often says something narrower and more conditional than the version in circulation.
That produces no debunking. Most of these findings are real. But in nearly every case the striking number survived into popular use and its conditions did not — and the conditions are the practical content. The table below is the whole evidence base of the book, open for anyone to check.
How to read the labels
Holds up — reproduced by other researchers at roughly the reported size.
Conditional — real, but only under stated conditions, or rests on a single study or site.
Contested — failed to replicate, shrank substantially, or the usually quoted claim is not what the paper measured.
Not a study — trade practice, corporate anecdote or unpublished proprietary research. Useful, but not evidence of the same kind.
Synthesis — the entry is itself a meta-analysis or a paper that reconciles two earlier results. It is the yardstick, not a thing being measured.
All thirty sources
Chapter numbers refer to The Fourth Bottle. Full citations are in Appendix C of the book.
| # | Study | Headline figure | Replication status | Ch |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Iyengar & Lepper, JPSP — jam display 2000 | 60% / 40% stopped; 3% / 30% bought | Contested Contested. Near-zero mean in Scheibehenne 2010 meta-analysis; restored as conditional by Chernev 2015 | 4 |
| 2 | Scheibehenne, Greifeneder & Todd — meta-analysis, ~50 studies 2010 | Mean effect of assortment size ≈ zero | Synthesis | 4 |
| 3 | Chernev, Böckenholt & Goodman, JCP — 99 observations, N=7,202 2015 | Four moderators: set complexity, task difficulty, preference uncertainty, decision goal | Synthesis Reconciles 1 and 2 | 4, 5, 7 |
| 4 | P&G Head & Shoulders SKU cut 26→15 1997 | Sales +10%, reported Washington Post | Not a study Single company, single line. Corporate anecdote, not a study | 4 |
| 5 | Fragrance-trade testing guidance current | Cap of 3–4 fragrances per session; olfactory adaptation | Not a study Industry practice, convergent across sources; not an experiment | 4, 5 |
| 6 | Karmarkar, Shiv & Knutson, JMR — price primacy, fMRI 2015 | Price-first shifts valuation to “is it worth it”; product-first to “do I like it”. Purchase rates did not differ | Conditional Single study, student sample, small items | 1 |
| 7 | Mason, Lee, Wiley & Ames, JESP — precise first offers 2013 | N=1,254. Precise offers ($5,015 vs $5,000) read as better-informed; counterparts conceded more | Conditional Later work finds limits; see 8 | 2 |
| 8 | Lee, Loschelder, Schweinsberg, Mason & Galinsky, OBHDP 2018 | Precise offers deter aggressive counteroffers | Synthesis Extends 7 | 2 |
| 9 | Yang, Kimes & Sessarego, IJHM — menu price formats 2009 | N=201. No currency symbol → +$5.55 per head, ≈8%. Spelled-out prices no different from $ | Conditional Single site (CIA café) | 3, 9 |
| 10 | Ariely — The Economist subscription demonstration 2008 | 3 options: 16/0/84. 2 options: 68/32 | Contested Two large 2014 replication efforts largely failed with realistic stimuli | 6 |
| 11 | Huber, Payne & Puto — asymmetric dominance 1982 | Original decoy effect | Conditional Holds in abstract two-attribute paradigms only | 6 |
| 12 | Prelec & Loewenstein, Marketing Science — pain of paying 1998 | Pain driven by payment saliency and timing | Holds up Framework, widely built on | 8, 9 |
| 13 | Prelec & Simester, Marketing Letters — “Always leave home without it” 2001 | Credit-card bids up to 100% higher than cash, real Celtics tickets | Conditional Directionally replicated; magnitude varies | 8 |
| 14 | Shiv, Carmon & Ariely, JMR — marketing placebo 2005 | Discounted energy drink → worse puzzle performance than full price | Holds up Conceptually replicated (Fell & Eisend 2013) | 10 |
| 15 | Shampanier, Mazar & Ariely, Marketing Science — zero price 2007 | Hershey 1¢ / Lindt 15¢ → 27/73. Hershey free → inverts | Holds up Robust | 10 |
| 16 | Jia, Huang, Zhang, Shi & Zhang — final price neglect 2023 | Separated discounts beat integrated ones on higher-priced items | Conditional Recent, not yet replicated | 10 |
| 17 | Regan, JESP — unsolicited Coke 1971 | Raffle purchase 25% → 58% | Holds up Classic; reciprocity robust | 11 |
| 18 | Strohmetz, Rind, Fisher & Lynn, JASP — candy and tipping 2002 | Small candy gift raises tips | Holds up Replicated in tipping literature | 11 |
| 19 | Rind & Strohmetz, JASP — helpful message on the check 1999 | Mean tip ≈17% → ≈20% | Conditional Single server, single site | 11 |
| 20 | Server self-introduction by name — | Tip rate 15% → 23% (buffet setting) | Conditional Single study; widely cited in tipping work | 11 |
| 21 | Buell & Norton, Management Science — labor illusion 2011 | Five experiments. Visible effort → preference for longer waits, same results | Conditional Robust within domain | 11 |
| 22 | Peck & Shu, JCR — mere touch 2009 | Touch raises perceived ownership and valuation; imagery-of-touch works too | Conditional Four studies; touch valence matters | 11 |
| 23 | Goldstein, Cialdini & Griskevicius, JCR — hotel towels 2008 | 35.1% → 44.1% (p=.05); Exp 2 37.2% → 44.5% | Holds up Five replications, N=2,466, all p>.14. Bayesian synthesis of 7 studies: BF₁₀=36.89, effect real but ≈6 points, not 9 | 12 |
| 24 | Scheibehenne, Jamil & Wagenmakers, Psych Science — Bayesian synthesis 2016 | Reconciles 23 | Synthesis | 12 |
| 25 | Ein-Gar, Shiv & Tormala, JCR — blemishing effect 2012 | Small negative info raises favourability — only when it follows positives, is minor, and processing is low-effort | Holds up Four studies, lab and field | 12 |
| 26 | Worchel, Lee & Adewole, JPSP — cookie jar 1975 | 2-cookie jar rated more desirable than 10-cookie jar. Price measure not significant | Contested Desire yes, willingness-to-pay unproven | 12 |
| 27 | Freedman & Fraser, JPSP — foot in the door 1966 | 76% vs 16.7% agreed to large lawn sign | Conditional Classic; effect smaller in modern meta-analyses | 12 |
| 28 | Langer, Blank & Chanowitz, JPSP — photocopier 1978 | 5 pages: 60% / 94% / 93%. 20 pages: placebic reason stops working | Conditional Replicated within its conditions | 13 |
| 29 | Rackham / Huthwaite — photo-store closing study 1988 | Low-value: 72%→76% after closing training. High-value (avg $109): 42%→33% | Not a study Proprietary consulting research, never peer-reviewed, raw data never released | 13 |
| 30 | Rackham / Huthwaite — early-closing study 1988 | 30 high-close calls → 11 sales (37%). 30 low-close calls → 21 sales (70%) | Holds up Same caveat as 29 | 13 |
Five things worth knowing before you quote any of this
The standing caveats
The most-cited evidence in professional selling is the least checkable
Huthwaite’s 35,000-call corpus underpins most modern B2B sales training. It was proprietary consulting research, never peer-reviewed, and the raw data was never released. The book cites it, because it is the largest body of evidence there is, and says this plainly rather than treating it as settled science. The source even disagrees with itself on how long the study ran: the preface says twelve years, chapter one says ten.
A famous result about price order found no difference in what people bought
The price-primacy work (Karmarkar, Shiv & Knutson, 2015) found that showing the price first shifts the brain toward “is it worth it” and the product first toward “do I like it”. Purchase rates did not differ. Any advice built on it has to say so.
The decoy effect is a laboratory phenomenon first
Asymmetric dominance is real and reliable in abstract two-attribute choices. Two large replication efforts in 2014 largely failed to reproduce it with realistic stimuli. The book presents it as a layout principle, not a lever you can pull.
The towel sign is real, and it is smaller than you were told
Famous number: a 9-point lift. Five replications with 2,466 guests found nothing. A Bayesian synthesis of all seven studies (Scheibehenne, Jamil & Wagenmakers, 2016) put the Bayes factor at 36.89 and the effect at roughly 6 points. Both the “it works” and the “it failed” camps were reading one half of the evidence.
Scarcity raises desire. The study usually cited never showed it raises price
In the cookie-jar experiment (Worchel, Lee & Adewole, 1975) the two-cookie jar was rated more desirable than the ten-cookie jar. The willingness-to-pay measure was not significant. That distinction matters a great deal if you are about to cut your stock to raise your margin.
Questions this page gets asked
Did the jam study replicate?
Is the hotel towel social proof effect real?
Is SPIN Selling based on real data?
Does the decoy effect work on real products?
Which findings in the book have the strongest evidence?
Why include findings you say are weak?
Where these thirty studies turn into something you can use
The table says what the evidence is. The book says what to do about it: the situation each finding applies to, the words to use, and the conditions under which it stops working.
